Five decades of steady protection

We help churches, schools, nonprofits, and businesses protect what matters with thoughtful coverage, responsive service, and long-term partnership.

The people behind Anchor

Experienced professionals who understand the industries we serve and the responsibility that comes with protecting them.

Dallas, TX Office

Rick McCrary

Partner

555-555-5555

Learn More

Brandon McCrary

Partner, CEO

555-555-5555

Learn More

Paula Burns

Partner, VP of Risk Management

555-555-5555

Learn More

Lindsey Lyons

COO

555-555-5555

Learn More

John Lyons

VP of Business Development

555-555-5555

Learn More

Amanda Koch

Marketing Manager

555-555-5555

Learn More

Ray McLeod

Business Development Executive

555-555-5555

Learn More

Edward Dave

Business Development Executive

555-555-5555

Learn More

Keith Smith

Business Development Executive

555-555-5555

Learn More

Woodlands, TX Office

Gary Benson

Position

555-555-5555

Learn More

Julie Bergeron

Sr. Commercial Lines Account Manager

555-555-5555

Learn More

Indianapolis, IN Office

Dough Kafoure

Business Development Executive

555-555-5555

Learn More

How we protect you

Insurance works best when it's built around your actual needs. We listen, assess, and deliver coverage that fits.

Risk Assessment

Our agents spend time understanding your operations, exposures, and concerns before recommending coverage.

Carrier Access

We partner with over fifteen insurers, giving you options and competitive rates instead of a single solution.

Custom Policies

One size never fits all. We build coverage that addresses your specific risks and budget constraints.

Ongoing Support

Your needs change. We are available to review your coverage and adjust as your organization grows and evolves.

Ready to protect what matters

Get a personalized quote and risk assessment from our team. We'll show you what proper coverage looks like.

Built on a foundation of results

Our agents spend time understanding your operations, exposures, and concerns before recommending coverage.

Years of experience

Decades of experience protecting misson-driven organizations.

Carrier Partners

Top-tier insurers to find you the best possible coverage

Clients

Local presence with nationwide reach and resources

Nationwide Coverage

States served with business insurance and risk solutions

Questions

Clear answers to questions about our agency and how we're different

What types of insurance coverage does a church actually need?

Most churches need more than a standard property and liability policy. Coverage often includes property insurance, general liability, abuse and molestation protection, pastoral counseling liability, directors and officers (D&O) coverage, workers’ compensation, cyber liability, commercial auto, and coverage for special events or missions activities. The right structure depends on how your church operates, who uses your facilities, and the risks connected to your ministries.

How much church insurance coverage is enough for our ministry?

The right coverage limits depend on your property value, staff size, volunteer structure, transportation exposure, counseling activities, childcare programs, and how often your facilities are used throughout the week. Many churches discover their coverage no longer reflects how their ministry actually operates. A proper insurance review should evaluate both protection gaps and areas where coverage can be better aligned to your current needs. Through our Risk Navigation approach, we help churches move beyond generic policies and toward a more thoughtful, ministry-specific protection strategy.

Does our church need abuse and molestation coverage?

Any church working with children, students, or vulnerable populations should strongly consider abuse and molestation coverage as part of its overall risk management strategy. Just as important as the policy itself are the church’s screening procedures, volunteer training, supervision standards, and reporting processes. Insurance should support a broader commitment to protecting people and strengthening ministry safety practices. Our team helps churches approach this topic proactively and responsibly.

Can churches lower insurance costs without sacrificing protection?

Sometimes, yes. Insurance costs can often be improved through stronger safety practices, updated property valuations, better claims prevention strategies, cybersecurity improvements, driver policies, and clearer ministry procedures. Our goal is not to simply find the cheapest premium, it is to build a sustainable risk strategy that protects the church while being a wise steward of ministry resources. We partner directly with insurance providers that offer specific coverage that churches need.

Why do churches need a specialized insurance agency instead of standard business insurance?

Churches face unique risks that many standard business insurance programs are not designed to address. Worship services, counseling ministries, volunteers, childcare, missions work, special events, and community facilities all create exposures that require specialized understanding. Working with an agency experienced in church insurance helps ensure coverage decisions align with how ministry actually functions day to day. Our specialists are uniquely equipped to help church leaders navigate their coverage options.

Have another question?

Reach out to our team.

Premium Carriers. Personalized Coverage.

Get your quote today

Tell us about your organization and we'll send a customized quote.